Conversation
Notices
-
q: What would !AGPL for content be? a: src-requiring copyleft ie [A]GPL? http://forum.creativecommons.org/topic/587#post-1601
Monday, 04-Jul-11 00:31:46 UTC from web-
@mlinksva we don't even have a GPL for content in the cc world. no src requirement there whereas the GPL has one.
-
@zotz why not use the GPL?
-
@mlinksva it does not fit non-code well. source vs binaries for one thing. do we need a project to get wording right for src not for code?
-
@zotz wording of http://www.gnu.org/licenses/gpl.html#section1 seems general to me.
-
@mlinksva doesn't sit well for me when thinking of applying to art/music/etc.
-
@zotz meaning GPL overall, or /src=preferred for modification, object=!src/ specifically?
-
@mlinksva at least the object/src stuff and perhaps the aiming at programs/code in general. possibly even emphasis of FSF to software...
-
@zotz yes those are all annoyances, unclear should be dealbreakers. I recognize they could've/might have some salutary effects as well…
-
@zotz …a)culture as software=future b)culture as sw good for freedom as more modular/more mass collab prod; makehappenfaster #speculation
-
@mlinksva FSF strong stance on SW Freedom but no for Art/Music Freedom may cause many problems. What is source for a statue? Sketches?
-
@zotz and we're talking about the GPL, not the FSF's verbatim copying notice ;-)
-
@zotz src of course is problematic. are you arguing there shouldn't be an option for src-requiring copyleft for art?
-
@zotz and note that src could in theory be similarly problematic for sw too where machine learning/self-mod involved #cuttingroomfloor
-
http://comments.gmane.org/gmane.comp.gis.openstreetmap.legal/6261 fundamentally about figuring out src-requiring copyleft&non-sw #odbl
-
@mlinksva I don't, but at least CC doesn't take a strong stand in their main area. Whereas I like FSF strong stand in their main area but...
-
@mlinksva no, there should likely be one, but it needs a better definition and explanation than the GPL has.
-
@mlinksva that may indeed be a bridge to be crossed.
-
All Identi.ca content and data are available under the