@bkuhn Influenced in part by your advocacy, yesterday I announced that, effective immediately, the many JBoss projects must cease use of CLAs (with the only exception being ones that are JSR RI projects where there might be a JCP-imposed CLA requirement).
I think the thing that really made me decide to do this was a comment on the FLOSS Foundations list from a very prominent developer in the history of free software/open source who defended the use of CLAs on grounds of 'hygiene'. As I told someone off-list, this comment made me physically ill. I had to do something.
The JBoss projects were really the only Red Hat-maintained projects left that made use of CLAs, apart from the odd case of the Fedora Project Contributor Agreement (which implements spot's idea of 'default MIT/X11 licensing', a replacement for an older Apache-style CLA which was politically unpopular). Cygwin continues to use copyright assignment and probably will for all time (though I have suggested to the Red Hat maintainer that the copyright be assigned to her rather than to Red Hat). But that's it.
I think the thing that really made me decide to do this was a comment on the FLOSS Foundations list from a very prominent developer in the history of free software/open source who defended the use of CLAs on grounds of 'hygiene'. As I told someone off-list, this comment made me physically ill. I had to do something.
The JBoss projects were really the only Red Hat-maintained projects left that made use of CLAs, apart from the odd case of the Fedora Project Contributor Agreement (which implements spot's idea of 'default MIT/X11 licensing', a replacement for an older Apache-style CLA which was politically unpopular). Cygwin continues to use copyright assignment and probably will for all time (though I have suggested to the Red Hat maintainer that the copyright be assigned to her rather than to Red Hat). But that's it.
Cygwin continues to use copyright assignment and probably will for all time
Actually not as of yesterday. :)
Actually not as of yesterday. :)
Richard Fontana at 2016-06-24T17:18:46Z
der.hans likes this.