- I remain amazed how being non-negative about Canonical attracts such hostility.First of all, thanks a lot for your in-depth answer to my previous comment (which I've noticed only now due to some lingering weirdness in pump.io notifications ;-)). I wonder, did you get specific negative / anti-canonical feedbacks to your video interview with Mark this time? Yes, I'm very well aware of vitriolic anti-canonical feedback in other occasion, but this time, at least the discussion here on pump.io seems decent enough. It's "just" people with different limit-of-compromise, as you put it, but they all seem quite supportive of the attempt of having a "more" free smartphone on the market, don't you think? Just checking if our respective perceptions are completely skewed, and in different directions, or if you were referring to past episodes :-)Simon, I have no interest in giving you a hard time about doing an interview with Shuttleworth, but Shuttleworth has been quite aggressive in his opposition of folks who do my type of work. He's called me a McCarthyist and "insecure in my beliefs" because I uphold copyleft, and he's said that Canonical's business plan is to violate the GPL on Linux. At OSCON, when I told him as smalltalk I'm working hard on non-profits, Shuttleworth told me that non-profit executives were overpaid and not held accountable enough like for-profit executives. The guy treats people who fight for software freedom with contempt. He can do what he wants, and I'm not condemning you for interviewing someone rich and famous, but he's not really focused on working for software freedom. Software freedom is a means to a different end for him. http://ebb.org/bkuhn/blog/2012/12/14/unamerican-mccarthyist-cancer.html is my full post about Shuttleworth's comments on Linux GPL enforcement.
Claes Wallin (韋嘉誠) likes this.
- Bruce Sterling on The Ecuadorian Library:
"People, you couldn’t trust any of these three guys to go down to the corner grocery for a pack of cigarettes. Stallman would bring you tiny peat-pots of baby tobacco plants, then tell you to grow your own. Assange would buy the cigarettes, but smoke them all himself while coding up something unworkable. And Ed would set fire to himself, to prove to an innocent mankind that tobacco is a monstrous and cancerous evil that must be exposed at all costs.(via @GlynMoody)
And yet the three of them together, they look just amazing. They are fantastic figures, like the promise of otherworldly aid from a superhero comic. They are visibly stronger than they’ve ever been before. They have the initiative in a world afflicted with comprehensive helplessness."
I'm not sure I really understand that quote :-) But that picture is pretty powerful, though!
All three are heroes of mine for some things they've done. That doesn't mean I have to agree with them on every issue or that I look to them for "perfect role models" in other aspects of life.
Also I'm OK with them not buying cigarettes for their friends, no one should :-)
Claes Wallin (韋嘉誠) likes this.
- I checked the transcript of the video and Mark Shuttleworth definitely committed to Free software in the Edge phone:
Simon: So what’s going to be in there? That’s all going to be free software?
Mark: Yes, we’ll ship this with Android and Ubuntu, no plans to put proprietary applications on it. We haven’t finalised the silicon selection so we’re looking at the next generation silicon from all major vendors. I would like to ship it with all Free drivers.
Greg Grossmeier shared this.Show all 11 replies
ATM using a 3rd party client is the only way to get formatted comments. See: https://github.com/e14n/pump.io/wiki/Clients#desktop
Simon, I want to believe you are right with regard to Mark Shuttleworth, i.e. that his ultimate goal is software freedom, and he is just making different strategic choices than others. But with them even making proprietary software in house (i.e. Ubuntu One, and Launchpad earlier) I have a hard time doing that.
- I recorded an interview about Ubuntu Edge with Mark Shuttleworth last week at OSCON: http://youtu.be/-HNFBHwcrFM
- Great list of features and strengths shows the energy of the LibreOffice community: https://www.libreoffice.org/features/why-libreoffice
Evan Prodromou likes this.
James Bryce Clark shared this.
- Does anyone have a cartridge to run pump.io on OpenShift yet? Looks like ideal trainer wheels for a new user.
- Github finally agrees that repos need a copyright license to ensure users have software freedom: http://www.infoworld.com/d/open-source-software/github-finally-takes-open-source-licenses-seriously-...
- AMD Joins The Document Foundation advisory board to accelerate LibreOffice: http://ur1.ca/eilxw
- Know anyone starting a FOSS project? Tell them about these OSCON sessions from @bkuhn & I: http://ur1.ca/efwxt
- Computer scientists urge court to block copyright claims in Oracle v. Google API fight: https://eff.org/r.2bS4
Simon Phipps likes this.